Could the n-body problem be a macroscopic manifestation of the Heisenberg and Born Uncertainty Principle? Thank you.

- Thread starter Carl James Mesaros
- Start date

Could the n-body problem be a macroscopic manifestation of the Heisenberg and Born Uncertainty Principle? Thank you.

Moreover, almost any model for the $n$ body problem is deterministic so it can't possibly be related to say the Heisenberg uncertainty principle which is a statement about how well one can simultaneously understand a probability distribution and its Fourier transform.

It seems like you are just saying some words you heard in a class. If this isn't the case, try to ask a more pointed and coherent question.

Actually we

Moreover, almost any model for the $n$ body problem is deterministic so it can't possibly be related to say the Heisenberg uncertainty principle which is a statement about how well one can simultaneously understand a probability distribution and its Fourier transform.

It seems like you are just saying some words you heard in a class. If this isn't the case, try to ask a more pointed and coherent question.

For example we do have a simple case of the 2 body problem: The hydrogen atom (proton and electron) has a closed form solution. But trying to do this with deuterium (1 proton, 1 neutron, and an electron) is impossible. You would have to approximate a solution.

There is no macroscopic version of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. That is a purely QM effect. Nor is there a macroscopic version of Born's Lemma. We'd have to assume that a macroscopic particle has a wave-like character and it doesn't.

I have to agree with SDK. I can't see where you would find an example of this statement in any respectable Physics paper or text. It sounds like it's made up. I would suggest you abandon your reading material and find a better source.

-Dan

Last edited:

presumptuous as to ask such a question without having my facts straight!

It happens. It's better to ask the question than for it to be a stopping point for you at some later time. Always ask questions!

presumptuous as to ask such a question without having my facts straight!

-Dan

I think you are confusing a system which is chaotic with a stochastic system. The classical $n$-body problem is a deterministic, but chaotic system. Actually this isn't quite true. For $n = 2$ it is known to be integrable (hence not chaotic) and I think it has only been proved chaotic for $n =$ 3 and 4, but certainly it is widely believed to be true for all $ n \geq 3$. Anyway, being chaotic does not mean that the position can not be determined. For example, we know exactly where the moon is despite its position being determined (primarily) by the gravitational field of other bodies.

presumptuous as to ask such a question without having my facts straight!

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle on the other hand is not related to chaos at all. It says that if a probability distribution has a small variance, then its Fourier transform has a large variance. When applied to objects which have wave-like properties, their position/momentum obey distributions and one is the Fourier transform of the other. So this can be interpreted as saying that the position of a particle and its momentum can not both be precisely determined. This is a fundamental property of the fact that the system is stochastic.

tldr; To the best of my knowledge there is no relationship between the $n$-body problem and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

Oooh! I like the wording on the variance thing. Nice job.The Heisenberg uncertainty principle on the other hand is not related to chaos at all. It says that if a probability distribution has a small variance, then its Fourier transform has a large variance. When applied to objects which have wave-like properties, their position/momentum obey distributions and one is the Fourier transform of the other. So this can be interpreted as saying that the position of a particle and its momentum can not both be precisely determined. This is a fundamental property of the fact that the system is stochastic.

tldr; To the best of my knowledge there is no relationship between the $n$-body problem and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

You are correct: There is no connection between the Heisenberg principle and the n-body problem.

-Dan

Similar Math Discussions | Math Forum | Date |
---|---|---|

The N-Body Problem or the Uncertainty Principle? | Physics | |

The N-Body problem, what can we know? | Physics | |

Doubt with a free body diagram problem | Physics | |

Differentiation Problem Can Anybody Help | Calculus |